# PSA vs Beckett vs CGC: Fees, Standards and Resale Compared

> PSA vs Beckett vs CGC compared: per-card fees, turnaround, value caps and resale, plus TAG and a quick-answer list for choosing a grading company.

Published 2026-11-07, updated 2026-11-17, by Buddy.
Original: https://www.joinbuddy.cards/blog/psa-vs-beckett-vs-cgc-comparing-the-top-card-grading-companies

Beckett has the lowest entry fee of the four majors, CGC is the value pick with the widest range of paid tiers, and PSA charges the most but sells for the strongest resale premiums. As of November 2026, PSA's Regular tier is $79.99 per card, CGC's Standard tier is £54 and Beckett's Base tier is $14.95, according to tcgrader.com [1].

This list is published by the makers of Buddy and judged by four criteria: fee per card, turnaround, value cap per tier, and how the slab sells afterwards. Prices reflect figures published as of November 2026. Graders pause tiers often, so check each company's own page before you submit.

## Quick answer

- Best for the strongest resale premiums: PSA, because tcgrader.com says PSA slabs "typically sell for the highest premiums" [1].
- Best for cheap bulk submissions: CGC, because its Bulk Economy tier is $17 per card with a 25-card minimum [2].
- Best for the lowest entry fee: Beckett (BGS), because its Base tier is $14.95 per card, per tcgrader.com [1].
- Best for a transparent digital report on each card: TAG, because tcgrader.com says it publishes one for every card [1].
- Best for Pokémon collectors who want the grade, value and a fake check before paying a fee: Buddy, because it estimates the odds of each grade from PSA, CGC, Beckett, TAG and SGC from your photos.

## Why people look for an alternative to PSA

People leave PSA, or at least look beyond it, mainly over fees, waiting times and paused tiers. PSA is the market leader, but tcgrader.com notes that "that demand shows in both fees and turnaround" and that PSA "has repeatedly paused its cheaper Value tiers during backlogs, which means the cheapest advertised price is often not actually available" [1].

PSA's own grading page, read in November 2026, shows a banner: "Value Services Are Temporarily Paused." The tiers it lists are priced from $39.99 (Value Bulk, 90 to 100 business days) through $79.99 (Regular, 50 to 60 business days) up to Premium tiers of $999 and above [3]. PSA also states that its estimated turnaround times are "estimates only and not guaranteed" [3].

There is a second reason: the surrounding costs. A cardvaluefinder.com worked example puts the real price of five cards at roughly $34 per card rather than the $25 advertised, once shipping out and back is added [4]. Tcgrader.com puts tracked, insured postage to and from a grader at $15 to $40 per submission [1].

None of this means PSA is a bad choice. Forum posters on Elite Fourum still lean PSA for resale. One writes that "if you're selling, you will get the biggest bang for your buck at PSA" [5]. The alternatives matter when your card is worth less than the top tiers justify, or when you do not want to wait months.

## The options at a glance

Most grading companies publish clear base rates, so the table lists entry prices and maximum values for each tier. Check PSA and CGC pricing directly on their sites; view Beckett and TAG rates on tcgrader.com. All were read in November 2026.

| Option | Best for | Entry price and top tier | Turnaround at entry | One limit |
| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- |
| Buddy | Pokémon collectors checking grade odds, fakes and value before paying | From $9.99 a month (Free plan available) | Photo-based estimate | An estimate, not a graded slab |
| PSA | Resale value | $39.99 per card, Value Bulk (paused) [3]; $79.99 per card, Regular; $999 per card, Premium 1 | 50 to 60 business days at Regular [3] | Value tiers paused as of November 2026 |
| CGC | Low-cost bulk | $17 per item, Bulk Economy; £19 per item, Economy; £288 per item, WalkThrough [2] | 150 business days at Bulk Economy | Bulk needs 25 cards minimum |
| Beckett (BGS) | Lowest fee, subgrades | $14.95 per card, Base; $124.95 per card, Priority, per tcgrader.com [1] | About 3 months at Base | Subgrades cost extra |
| TAG | Digital grading report | $39 per card, Standard (paused); $59 per card, Express, per tcgrader.com [1] | About 10 days at Express | Cheaper tiers sold out for long stretches |

Prices checked on 6 Nov 2026.

Misprint.com lists TAG at $12-15 per card at its economy level compared to $20 for PSA [6]. Verify current tier details directly on Misprint.com before submitting your cards.

## Buddy: check grade odds and fakes before you pay a fee

Buddy is an AI-powered Pokémon card grader for iPhone. You photograph a card, and it estimates the grade a grading company would give it, so you know what you are likely to get back before the fee is spent.

That matters because every fee in this article is charged whether the card returns a 10 or a 7. Tcgrader.com calls this "the bad-grade tax": "The fee is the same whether you get the 10 or not" [1]. In Buddy you get the estimated odds of each grade from PSA, CGC, Beckett, TAG and SGC from one set of photos, so you can compare companies for the specific card in your hand.

Centering is the first thing it measures. Buddy checks centering against grader standards for a potential 10, which tells you early whether a card is worth submitting at all.

It also helps on the buying side. Buddy checks Pokémon cards for authenticity by examining lettering, numbers, print and foil against real cards, and it gives pricing information based on real sales data from platforms like eBay and TCGplayer. That lets you set the break-even point against the fees in the table above.

Buddy is free with unlimited scans, 3 grades and 1 listing check a month. Pro is $9.99 a month or $59.99 a year, and you can also buy a pack of 10 grades for $4.99.

The estimate is a pre-grading check for you, not a graded slab. If you need an actual encapsulated grade, PSA or CGC fits better.

## PSA: highest resale premiums, slowest and priciest

PSA is the pick when resale value drives the decision. Tcgrader.com says PSA slabs "typically sell for the highest premiums" [1], and forum users on Elite Fourum back that up: one says "in terms of value, liquidity and overall demand, I feel PSA is definitely at the top in Pokemon" [5].

PSA's own page, read in November 2026, lists these tiers per card [3]:

| Tier | Fee per card | Max insured value | Estimated turnaround |
| --- | --- | --- | --- |
| Value Bulk | $39.99 | $500 | 90 to 100 business days |
| Value | $59.99 | $1,000 | 70 to 80 business days |
| Regular | $79.99 | $1,500 | 50 to 60 business days |
| Express | $199.00 | $2,500 | 20 to 30 business days |
| Super Express | $349.00 | $5,000 | 10 to 15 business days |
| Walk-Through | $599.00 | $10,000 | 7 to 10 business days |
| Premium 1 | $999.00 | $25,000 or less | 5 to 7 business days |

The page also lists Premium 2 ($1,999), Premium 3 ($2,999), Premium 5 ($4,999) and Premium 10 (from $9,999) for higher-value items [3]. Note that tcgrader.com lists some of these with different fees and times, such as Express at $149, because third-party tables lag the grader's page [1]. Trust the grader's page for the live number.

Who it suits: you plan to sell, and the card can reach a high grade. The limit: the cheaper Value tiers are paused as of November 2026, so the lowest fee you can actually pay is higher than the lowest fee advertised.

## CGC: the value pick with a wide fee range

CGC is the pick when you want a low fee, a short wait on paid tiers, or a large batch. Its own services page, read in November 2026, lists these card tiers per item [2]:

| Tier | Fee | Estimated turnaround | Max fair market value |
| --- | --- | --- | --- |
| Bulk Economy | $17 | 150 business days | $500 (min 25 items) |
| Economy | $20 | 90 business days | $1,000 |
| Standard | $55 | 10 business days | $3,000 |
| Express | $100 | 5 business days | $10,000 |
| WalkThrough | $300 | 2 business days | $100,000 |
| Unlimited Value | $300 plus 1% of FMV | 2 business days | Unlimited |

CGC's page adds a warning: if it decides a collectible's fair market value is higher than you declared, it "will move the collectible to the appropriate higher tier and the additional charge will be the responsibility of the submitter" [2].

Community opinion is mixed. On Elite Fourum, one collector leans CGC for personal collections because "their slabs and scans look better" but adds that the market seems to prefer PSA for resale [5]. Another poster lists CGC cons as multiple grading scales and lower market value [5]. Tcgrader.com puts it in money terms: CGC slabs "generally resell for less than the PSA equivalent, so the cheaper fee is not automatically the better net outcome" [1].

Who it suits: you want the cheapest real fee, or a fast paid tier for a mid-value card. The limit: lower resale premium than a PSA slab, and the 150-business-day wait at Bulk Economy.

## Beckett (BGS): lowest fee, subgrades and the black label

Beckett has the lowest entry fee of the four majors. Tcgrader.com, read in November 2026, lists these Beckett tiers per card [1]:

| Tier | Fee per card | Estimated turnaround | Max card value |
| --- | --- | --- | --- |
| Base | $14.95 | about 3 months | No cap |
| Base with Subgrades | $17.95 | about 3 months | No cap |
| Standard | $34.95 | about 2 months | No cap |
| Express | $79.95 | about 15 days | No cap |
| Priority | $124.95 | about 5 days | No cap |

The same source says BGS subgrades and the black label "still carry real cachet with vintage and high-end collectors" and warns that base-tier turnaround is slow and that subgrades cost extra, even though "the classic BGS look most buyers expect includes them" [1]. PXG's guide describes Beckett as using category subgrades with half-point increments [7].

Treat these third-party estimates from November 2026 as general guides and confirm current pricing on Beckett's site.

Who it suits: you want a low fee, no value cap, and subgrades to explain the grade. The limit: the slow base tiers and the extra cost of subgrades.

## TAG: transparent reports, limited capacity

TAG suits collectors who want a documented, machine-assisted grade for each card. Tcgrader.com says TAG "grades with a fully transparent computer-vision process and publishes a digital report for every card, which collectors increasingly value" [1]. PXG's guide describes the process as machine-learning imaging followed by human verification [7]. A forum poster calls TAG "a clear winner" for best-looking slabs and says it gives "a clear breakdown of why a card gets a certain grade" [5].

Tcgrader.com lists TAG's tiers per card as Basic $22 (paused, 10-card minimum), Standard $39 (paused), Express $59 (about 10 days, $1,000 cap), Priority $149 (about 5 days, $2,500 cap) and Walkthrough $299 (about 3 days, $5,000 cap) [1].

The limit is capacity. The same source says TAG "has sold out its cheaper tiers for extended stretches," so "the practically available price is often the Express tier and up" [1]. TAG slabs carry their own market value, so do not assume their resale prices match PSA.

## Is Beckett or PSA better?

PSA is better for resale and liquidity, and Beckett is better on entry price and subgrade detail. Tcgrader.com puts Beckett's Base tier at $14.95 against PSA's Regular at $79.99, and says PSA slabs sell for the highest premiums [1].

The forum consensus leans PSA for selling. One Elite Fourum poster says "if you're in it for money / liquidity, PSA is probably your best bet currently" [5]. A cons list on the same thread complains that PSA's idea of "authentic" is arguably too strict for test prints and errors [5]. Choose by what the card is for. A vintage or high-end card where subgrades matter can justify Beckett; a modern Pokémon card you plan to flip usually points to PSA.

## Does CGC have the same value as PSA?

No. CGC slabs generally resell for less than the PSA equivalent, according to tcgrader.com, which says to run your card through a calculator to see the difference at each grade [1].

The Elite Fourum thread gives a collector's view of the same gap: CGC 10s "can also command a decent premium (just not PSA 10 value typically)" [5]. If resale is the goal, run the arithmetic with the break-even formula that cardvaluefinder.com gives: grading is worth it when the graded market value minus the raw card's market value is greater than the total grading cost, which includes the fee, shipping out, return shipping and insurance [4]. If you are grading for looks or a personal binder, CGC's lower fee can be the better deal.

## What is card grading and what does it really cost?

Card grading is a professional assessment of a card's condition, after which the card is sealed in a protective holder with a label showing the grade and a certification number. PXG's guide says graders generally look at four areas: centering, corners, edges and surface [7]. The same guide cautions that grading "does not guarantee that a card will increase in value" [7].

The fee is only part of the cost. Cardvaluefinder.com lists outbound shipping at $10 to $30 per batch, return shipping at $15 to $40, insurance at $5 to $50 or more depending on declared value, and supplies at $5 to $15 per batch [4]. Tcgrader.com adds possible costs for some PSA tiers that need a paid Collectors Club membership, and says declared-value upcharges can move a card to a pricier tier [1].

That is why a pre-check pays off. Run your photos through Buddy first to see the estimated odds of each grade, the centering result and the sales-based price, then decide whether the card clears the break-even line.

## How to choose

Match the company to what the card is for. Resale value, budget and wait time pull in different directions.

- Pick Buddy if you collect Pokémon cards and want the estimated odds of each grade from PSA, CGC, Beckett, TAG and SGC, a fake check and sales-based pricing before you spend a grading fee.
- Pick PSA if you plan to sell and want the strongest resale premium; community posters and tcgrader.com both point to PSA for liquidity [5].
- Pick CGC if you want low fees on bulk or mid-value cards, such as $17 per item at Bulk Economy or £54 at Standard with a 10-business-day estimate [2].
- Pick Beckett if you want the lowest entry fee, no value cap and subgrades, and can accept about three months at the base tier [1].
- Pick TAG if you want a digital report on every card and can submit at Express or above, where tcgrader.com says capacity is actually available [1].

One note on non-big-name options: PXG describes itself as combining AI-assisted analysis with human grading, with one overall grade and no subgrades [7]. That is the company's own account, so verify its pricing and market acceptance yourself.

## Frequently asked questions

### Is Beckett or PSA better?

PSA is better for resale premiums, and Beckett is better on entry fee and subgrades. Tcgrader.com puts Beckett's Base tier at $14.95 against PSA's Regular at $79.99, while noting PSA slabs typically sell for the highest premiums [1].

### What is card grading?

Card grading is a professional condition assessment in which a company assigns a numerical grade and seals the card in a labelled slab. PXG's guide says graders look at centering, corners, edges and surface [7].

### Does CGC have the same value as PSA?

Not usually. Tcgrader.com says CGC slabs generally resell for less than the PSA equivalent, so the lower fee is not automatically the better net result [1]. A forum poster says CGC 10s command a decent premium, just not PSA 10 value typically [5].

### How much does PSA grading cost compared with CGC?

As of November 2026, PSA's own page lists Regular at $79.99 per card with a 50 to 60 business day estimate [3]. CGC's own page lists Economy at £19 per item and Standard at £54 per item with a 10-business-day estimate [2].

### What does grading cost beyond the fee?

Shipping, insurance and supplies add to the fee. Cardvaluefinder.com's worked example turns five cards at an advertised $25 each into about $34 per card once shipping is added [4]. Tcgrader.com puts tracked, insured postage at $15 to $40 per submission [1].

## Sources

1. [Beckett prices, per tcgrader.com: How much does card grading cost in 2026?](https://www.tcgrader.com/card-grading-costs?srsltid=AYCX9vLHhq_OvcJfZmZT0sm0_78qXL2p1m88oHR54ArGVWnJJBHIUOIu) (tcgrader.com)
2. [CGC prices: Services & Fees](https://www.cgcgrading.com/submit/services/) (cgcgrading.com)
3. [PSA prices: Grading](https://www.psacard.com/services/tradingcardgrading) (psacard.com)
4. [SGC prices, per cardvaluefinder.com: The Grading Premium: Real Examples](https://www.cardvaluefinder.com/sports-card-grading-cost/) (cardvaluefinder.com)
5. [CGC vs PSA - Grading](https://www.elitefourum.com/t/cgc-vs-psa/49520) (elitefourum.com)
6. [TAG prices, per misprint.com: PSA vs TAG: Is TAG Worth It Yet?](https://www.misprint.com/posts/psa-vs-tag-is-tag-worth-it?srsltid=AYCX9vIBjcs0mJHGoe7KWQpz_WYqEJRiUUKOUdWnCFNWnEr76DBYPrjZ) (misprint.com)
7. [PXG vs PSA, BGS, SGC, CGC, and TAG: A Comparative Guide](https://pxgrading.com/pxg-vs-psa-beckett-sgc-cgc-and-tag-which-card-grading-company-is-right-for-you/) (pxgrading.com)
