Buddy

Beckett vs PSA grading: cost, scale and resale compared

Beckett vs PSA grading compared: scales, fees per tier, turnaround, value caps and resale, with a table of PSA, Beckett, CGC and TAG options.

Updated 7 min read

Buddy card collection screen
On this page
  1. Quick answer
  2. Why people look for an alternative to PSA
  3. The options at a glance
  4. PSA
  5. Beckett (BGS)
  6. CGC
  7. TAG
  8. Check the likely grade with Buddy before you pay
  9. How to choose
  10. Frequently asked questions
  11. Sources

Beckett (BGS) has the lower entry fee and PSA has the stronger resale reputation, but both grade on a 1-10 scale and both charge by tier. According to TCGrader's 2026 cost guide, Beckett starts at $14.95 per card and PSA at $79.99, with PSA slabs "typically" selling "for the highest premiums"1. This page is a comparison of the grading companies themselves. It is published by the makers of Buddy, an app that estimates the grade a card would get, and it is judged on the same criteria for every company: scale, fee, turnaround, value cap and resale.

Quick answer

  • Best for the lowest entry fee: Beckett, because its Base tier is $14.95 per card, as of November 20261.
  • Best for resale premium: PSA, because TCGrader reports PSA slabs typically sell for the highest premiums1.
  • Best for half-grade detail: Beckett, because BGS also uses the 9.5 half point and a Black Label Pristine 102.
  • Best for cheap bulk TCG submissions: CGC, because its Bulk tier is $17 per card with a 25-card minimum1.

The criteria are scale, fee per card, turnaround, maximum declared value and resale.

Why people look for an alternative to PSA

People look past PSA mainly because of price and waiting time. TCGrader's guide says "PSA has repeatedly paused its cheaper Value tiers during backlogs, which means the cheapest advertised price is often not actually available"1. Public.com, in a guide updated April 2025, noted that grading services had been paused "due to an extreme backlog"2.

PSA also attaches conditions to its offers. Its specials page, read in November 2026, says turnaround times are "estimates only and not guaranteed" and may "change rapidly without notice"3. Third-party submission sellers add their own fees on top of grader prices. One Whatnot listing for ACE Grading charged £70.00 (approx. $93.68) plus shipping and taxes, as of November 20264.

The options at a glance

Four companies are compared here, with prices taken from TCGrader's 2026 cost guide, which says it refreshes from the graders' own published pricing (read November 2026). Each company publishes its current prices on its own site, so confirm there before you submit.

CompanyEntry price per cardFastest or top tierMax declared value at entry tierLimit
PSA$79.99, Regular1$999, Premium 11$1,500Cheaper tiers are sometimes paused
Beckett (BGS)$14.95, Base1$124.95, Priority1No capBase turnaround about 3 months
CGC$17, Bulk1£288, WalkThrough1$500Bulk needs 25 cards and takes about 5 months
TAG$22, Basic1$299, Walkthrough1$500Cheaper tiers often sold out

Prices checked on 6 Nov 2026.

The table covers the grading companies only. Shipping both ways, membership fees and declared-value upcharges come on top of these fees, per TCGrader1.

PSA

PSA is the market leader. TCGrader lists five tiers as of November 2026: Regular at $79.99 (about 2 months, $1,500 cap), Express at $149 (about 25 days, $2,500), Super Express at $349 (about 9 days, $5,000), Walk-Through at $599 (about 6 days, $10,000) and Premium 1 at $999 (about 6 days, $25,000)1.

PSA grades from 1 to 10 and avoids half points, according to Public.com2. For a PSA 10, Public.com says the front must measure between 55/45 and 60/40 on centering, and 70/30 on the reverse2.

It suits you if resale premium matters more than fee. The limit is cost and availability: PSA's specials page says turnaround estimates do not begin until the order is entered into the grading system3, and TCGrader notes that the cheapest tier is often not actually available1.

Beckett (BGS)

Beckett has the lowest entry price of the four majors in TCGrader's guide, at $14.95 for Base, rising to $17.95 with subgrades, $34.95 Standard, $79.95 Express and $124.95 Priority (as of November 2026)1. None of these tiers carries a value cap in that table.

Public.com says BGS uses the 9.5 half point and offers a Black Label Pristine 10, meaning a 10 on all four subgrades2. A BGS 10 requires 50/50 centering on the face and 60/40 on the back, which is less leeway than PSA2.

It suits you if you want subgrades and a low entry fee. The limit is speed and add-ons: Base turnaround is about 3 months, and TCGrader notes the classic BGS look most buyers expect includes subgrades, which cost extra1.

CGC

TCGrader calls CGC "usually the value pick for TCG submissions"1. As of November 2026 its tiers run Bulk $17 (about 5 months, $500 cap, 25-card minimum), Economy £19, Standard £54 (about 10 days), Express £96 (about 5 days), WalkThrough £288 and Unlimited Value £288 (about 2 days, no cap)1.

It suits you if you submit many lower-value cards and can wait, or if you want a fast paid tier without PSA prices. The limit is resale: the same guide says CGC slabs generally resell for less than the PSA equivalent, so "the cheaper fee is not automatically the better net outcome"1.

TAG

TAG grades with what TCGrader describes as a fully transparent computer-vision process and publishes a digital report for every card1. Its tiers are Basic $22, Standard $39, Express $59 (about 10 days), Priority $149 and Walkthrough $299 (about 3 days), as of November 20261.

It suits you if you value a per-card report and a fast, mid-priced tier. The limit is capacity: TCGrader marks Basic and Standard as paused or sold out and says the practically available price is often Express and up1.

Check the likely grade with Buddy before you pay

Buddy is not a grading company. It is an iPhone app that estimates the grade a grading company would give a card from photos, and it does not issue an official grade. It estimates the odds of each grade from PSA, CGC, Beckett, TAG and SGC, measures centering against grader standards for a potential 10, checks Pokémon cards for fakes by examining lettering, numbers, print and foil, and shows pricing based on real sales from platforms like eBay and TCGplayer. Its fake and price checks are built around Pokémon cards.

Consider the financial risk of receiving a low grade. TCGrader points out that the fee is the same "whether you get the 10 or not"1. A grade estimate and a sold-price check before you submit help you decide whether a $79.99 PSA fee or a $14.95 Beckett fee is worth paying for that card.

Buddy is free with unlimited scans, 3 grades and 1 listing check a month. Pro is $9.99 a month or $59.99 a year, and you can also buy a pack of 10 grades for $4.99. This article is published by the makers of Buddy.

How to choose

  • Pick PSA if you plan to sell and want the resale premium, and you can pay $79.99 or more per card1.
  • Pick Beckett if you want subgrades, half-point grades or the lowest entry fee at $14.952.
  • Pick CGC if you have 25 or more lower-value TCG cards and can wait months1.
  • Pick TAG if you want a digital report per card and can use the Express tier or above1.

A good order of work: estimate the grade, check recent sold prices, then match the card's declared value to a tier's cap.

Frequently asked questions

Is Beckett grading faster than PSA?

Not at the entry level. TCGrader lists Beckett Base at about 3 months and PSA Regular at about 2 months, as of November 20261. At the top, Beckett Priority is about 5 days and PSA Walk-Through about 6 days1. PSA says its estimates are not guaranteed3.

What is the difference between PSA and SGC grading for sports cards?

Check SGC's site for current pricing and grading scale details. Check SGC's own site for current prices. PSA uses a 1-10 grading scale without half points2.

How much does PSA charge for a $10,000 card?

TCGrader's table lists PSA Walk-Through at $599 per card with a $10,000 maximum card value, as of November 20261. Premium 1 is $999 and covers up to $25,0001. If PSA decides your card is worth more than you declared, it can move it to a pricier tier and bill the difference1.

How do you choose the right grading service for your cards?

Base your decision on your specific card type and target resale market. PSA slabs typically sell for the highest premiums, per TCGrader, while Beckett has lower entry pricing and offers subgrades1. Public.com notes that half a grade can change a card's value by thousands of dollars2.

Is PSA 1 or 10 better?

A 10 is the highest grade on the scale, so it is better for most cards. Public.com notes an exception: vintage cards can grade 2 or 3 and still be worth millions, such as a T206 Honus Wagner2.

Sources

  1. 1Beckett prices, per tcgrader.com: How much does card grading cost in 2026?tcgrader.com
  2. 2PSA Grading and BGS Grading: A Guidepublic.com
  3. 3PSA prices: PSA Grading Specialspsacard.com
  4. 4ACE Grading prices, per whatnot.com: Ace Grading - luxury servicewhatnot.com

Buddy is independent and isn’t affiliated with PSA, CGC, Beckett, TAG, SGC or The Pokémon Company. Fees and prices change; check the sources for the latest.

Check your next card before you send it off.

Buddy grades from two photos by the rules of PSA, CGC, Beckett, TAG and SGC, checks for fakes, and shows what it sells for.

Your phone
Download on the App Store

Free to download, with 3 free scans.

More articles